Free classified ads | Online Auctions | Our Weeklies | Long distance call | Weblocal |
The Westmount Examiner
Merkado Generique
Send this text to a friend Print this article Comment on this article

The Old Double Standard for Quebec

Richard Cléroux by Richard Cléroux
View all articles from Richard Cléroux
Article online since June 4th 2009, 11:52
Read all 10 comments about this article / Comment on this article
The Old Double Standard for Quebec
Lisa Raitt
The Old Double Standard for Quebec
Natural Resources Minister Lisa Raitt leaves her secret documents on nuclear installations in a CTV television studio.
Nobody in her office notices they are gone for six days. And these people are running the nuclear facilities at Chalk River.

No wonder the reactor is down and we’re running out of medical isotopes for the world.

But Raitt doesn’t have to resign. Instead they blame her 26-year old press aide Jasmine MacDonnell and she goes out on her ear.

“Totally incoherent,” said Bloc Québécois leader Gilles Duceppe. “The old double standard again.”

When Max Bernier forgets his secret documents at girlfriend Julie Couillard’s place, the gaffe is unforgivable and he gets dumped, no ifs, ands or buts.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper even moralizes about how ministers are responsible for their secret documents they must sign for and keep secure.

Then a year later all that is forgotten when Raitt does the same thing, She gets to stay though.

That’s because she’s a favourite of Harper’s, somebody he plucked out of the Port of Toronto, got her elected and brought her into cabinet – somebody he sees as a rising star. Falling star may be more like it now.

Bernier on the other hand was a liability and became a laughing stock passing out Jos Louis chocolate treats to Canadian soldiers facing life and death situations in Afghanistan.

As for Ms. MacDonnell, the best she can hope for is a good lawyer and a nice severance deal. Or else she goes public with the whole story.



But Harper is out of town in Quebec when the story breaks on CTV.

So Raitt is left to defend herself alone from an Opposition barrage in the Commons during Question Period. She has to get up 10 times on her feet to explain that she assumed her responsibilities.

Yeah, by dumping her aide.

A few seats over from her in the Commons, Bernier is chuckling like a school child with his seat-mate. Afterwards he tells reporters he has nothing to say.

The lost documents scandal couldn’t have come at a worse time for Raitt. She’s up to her ears in the Chalk River nuclear nightmare with isotope production ground to a halt and Canada looking bad in the eyes of the world. What a time to lose your documents.

No wonder she can’t run Chalk River, says Liberal MP David McGuinty.

Bloquiste Michel Guimond has another spin on it. He’s not so sure there is a double standard.

He thinks that in Bernier’s case the lost documents explanation may have been a pretext for dumping Bernier for something altogether more serious that has yet to come out.

Something to think about. It would help explain why Raitt got to keep her job and Bernier didn’t.

Your comments

Full name:
(required)


Email address:


Your comments :
(required)


Please retype the word displayed below Can't read the word?

Please retype the word displayed below:


Alex

Comment online since June 5th 2009
Minnie Peee:
Go back to school. "Incoherent" was used by Gilles Duceppe, in French, and it can definitely be used in the context of his sentence. "Incongruous", on the other hand, isn't synonymous with "incomprehensible", although close, it has a different meaning. Don't try to learn two languages, you obviously are having trouble with just one, okay dokey???.


Peter

Comment online since June 5th 2009
Why is it difficult to see that it was Bernier himself that carried the documents to a residence and there was no aide there to be responsible for the documents or as a partisan journalist you choose to ignore the obvious difference in the cases.
What is more important in this debacle is the conduct of a journalist who kept, snooped , photocopied and publicly disclosed contents of a document which he knew who they belonged to and that they were marked secret and were inadvertently left behind after official business. Do journalists have no ethics? Isn't material that is left behind or lost whether personal or government none of anybody's business or did parents of journalists have different standards and no ethics.

Minnie Peee

Comment online since June 4th 2009
Gilles! The word is not "incoherent",it's "incongruous", Okey dokey???? It means "incomprehensible".If I have to know two languages to live in this country "so do you Sir!!!!! Live in Canada Min.......

Chuck Mire

Comment online since June 4th 2009
Now that's rich ... the Lib-loving West Islanders of Montreal have been insulted because their boy Bernier was dumped insulting all Quebecois. Now I see why Duceppe wants Quebec 100% French .. to rid Quebec of the likes of you West Islanders. Oh..and please don't send your children to live in Toronto to escape the mess of your own making. Asse'est assez ....

terry boulanger

Comment online since June 4th 2009
dear bull an albert i m not from quebe a good ontario guy and i think rait should be fired on the dot. letting an 26 year old aid take the blame truly conservative always someone else fault. keep it up stephie boy

albertaclipper

Comment online since June 4th 2009
"Something to think about. It would help explain why Raitt got to keep her job and Bernier didn’t".
*******************************************************
Don't recall Raitt's boyfriend or husband being connected to your Hell's Angels.

Geez, you guys in Quebec have whining down to an art. And why should I be surprised. The ROC funds your ARTful whining.

bul durham

Comment online since June 4th 2009
A threat to Harper! lol
Quebec can't produce anything to threaten Harper nor ever could. And without forced bilingualism, would be invisible.

Andrew

Comment online since June 4th 2009
I agree completely, Richard. Quebeckers should protest this double standard by demanding that federal subsidies to Quebec should be reduced immediately so that tax money out of Quebec to the feds equals the amount of fed money returned to the province.

Pattipage

Comment online since June 4th 2009
Bernier was dumped because his star was rising,a threat to Harper; one mistake and out you go. Raitt is no threat to anyone.

bul doron

Comment online since June 4th 2009
Lisa Raitt makes the Ontario and Quebecer floppysition look like a bunch of Amateurs. lol

Related Newspapers






Quick Ravioli Bake

Recipe of the day

Quick Ravioli Bake

Serve with Spinach Salad. [+] More

Links