Chara hit on Pacioretty: Police investigation should be halted immediately



Chara's hit, while a disgusting, premeditated and dirty act, should not be the subject of a Montreal police investigation.

Chara's hit, while a disgusting, premeditated and dirty act, should not be the subject of a Montreal police investigation.

Marc Lalonde
Published on March 11, 2011
Published on March 11, 2011
Marc Lalonde  RSS Feed

Instead of prosecuting Chara, we should focus on real villains here: the NHL

Topics :
NHL , Bell Centre , Bruins , Montreal , Boston , Pittsburgh

In the wake of Zdeno Chara's devastatingly nasty, overwhelmingly dirty and complete anti-social act of running Max Pacioretty's head into a stanchion that divides the players' benches at the Bell Centre and the NHL's incredibly foolhardy decision not to suspend Chara or even fine him for the incident, Montreal police have been asked to open in investigation into the incident.

As much as I disliked the decision to not impose further discipline on the 6'9" behemoth who reminds some – me included – of the Frankenstein monster, both in size and in mental capacity, I don't know that this is a matter that should be investigated by civil authorities. I have long felt that civil authorities have no place in professional sports – especially those where body contact is legal, like hockey and football.

Don't mistake me, here, though. My gut feeling is that not only did Chara know where he was on the ice, but he also knew who he was jousting physically with. Chara and Pacioretty have a history dating back to January, when Pacioretty gave Chara an innocuous shove after scoring the winning goal in overtime.

After the game, the NESN play-by-play man made a comment to the effect of  'Chara's going to try to take that guy's head off,' and in the two teams' fight-filled Feb. 9 tussle in Boston, Chara gave Pacioretty a two-handed slash to the back of his legs that sent the winger off the ice for more than a few shifts. He didn't take his head off, but the strongest player in the NHL let Pacioretty know he was being watched, in no uncertain terms.

You mean to tell me that Chara didn't know the kid he'd spent months thinking about getting back at was right in his face with a chance to send a message in the last seconds of the second period of a game that had already become a blowout?

Please. I am still relatively young, but I wasn't born yesterday.

Dirty is dirty, and the Bruins know dirty; they know it well after they lost their best player, Marc Savard, possibly forever after he was blindsided with a shot to the head by Pittsburgh goon Matt Cooke last season. It remains a shame that Cooke, a marginal player who can, at best, be classified as an agitator is still on the ice, while Savard, a playmaker of the highest order, remains on the sidelines.

It's not right.

And the keepers of the hockey gospel – I'm looking at you, TSN's hockey chattering class of Dreger, Mackenzie et al. – still sing the praises of Philadelphia Flyers captain Mike Richards, a good player with a thin skin (his comments about PK Subban's jawing reflect the dinosaur hockey mentality), even though Richards helped start the head-shot debate when he blindsided the Panthers' David Booth in the head from the blind side.

The place for this, though, is not in our halls of justice. For one, no good can ever come of it (Todd Bertuzzi was given a conditional discharge for his mauling of Steve Moore after prosecution years ago) and once you let outside forces into your game, they're there forever.

Plus – and this is a big plus – Quebec's justice system is horribly overburdened and its prosecutors are underpaid. Can we at least let them focus on putting real offenders behind bars? Chara's hit outraged me and I sought to brand him a criminal, but upon reflection, I realized it was an emotional response to seeing our best young player lying in a heap at the very time he was blossoming into s superstar. The NHL, on the other hand, seems to be more and more out of touch with reality every day. Just ask Gary Bettman about his franchises in Phoenix, Miami and Atlanta, and how they're doing.

Comments

  • Username
    Shaun Lydon
    - March 27, 2011 at 17:42:30

    Th police definitely have a place to investigate such violent acts! Are you suggesting professionals sports are above the law? I highly disagree if that is what you are getting at. Everyone has to abide by the law and whether the sport you play allows physical contact or not, if a serious injury occurs and is caused by another player, it needs to be treated like anything else. Obviously organizations cannot take responsibilty to enforce such laws - they are a money making business and unfortunately the violence brings in money. So what is it going to take - a murder? If Chara did not mean to injury him then he should be charged with neglegance.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    elizabeth gilday
    - March 17, 2011 at 10:39:42

    With regards to hockey , violence fighting or otherwise The background story is liability insurance being covered or not for the result of so called violence considered a hockey play. Any criminal act will not be covered by insurance Therfore to date fighting or violence is to be considered a hockey play Checking player contracts and waivers of rights not allowed would be quite revealing spartica @hotmail tel 514 931 4947 westmount quebec

    Submit a Comment

  • Victor Levis
    Victor Levis
    - March 17, 2011 at 10:39:10

    Disgusting, premeditated, dirty acts of aggression are PRECISELY what should be the object of the authorities' efforts, UNLESS they are dealt with by another body, like a school, hockey league, etc. But of course, the league gets incident after incident wrong. Of course Chara should have been heavily punished for his venegful act on Pacioretty, but things didn't START there. Pacioretty should have been fined for his unsportsmanlike shoved. $1000 might have put a damper on the desire for revenge by the Bruins. Chara should have been suspended for the intentional, two-handed slash to the back of Pacioretty's leg. The Bruins should have been fined for the gooning during the last five minutes of a game they were WINNING. Gregory Campbell should have been suspended for punching Tom Pyatt repeatedly with an elbow pad and cutting his face open. Brad Marchand should have been fined for his inflammotory March 8th pre-game comments, saying things like the Habs deserved to get beaten up in Boston, etc. Players who trash talk for no reason should be sent off for ten minutes and suspended for a third offence. If this includes PK Subban, so be it. He is a smart guy, he will stop if he suffers a consequence. This trash talk point is important. You can't have a league preaching respect that permits gratuitous trash talk, name-calling, racial and homophobic epithets, references to players' sisters and mothers, etc. Trash talking adds NOTHING to the game and only incites some players to revenge. I manage the largest baseball league in Lac Saint Louis. Ever since we cracked down 5 years ago with consistent and stiffer punishments, and insisting especially on punishing unsportsmanlike acts, the general standard of behaviour has shot way up. No suprise there! The NHL can do the same, it is only a matter of will.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    Jean L. Wisintainer
    - March 17, 2011 at 10:38:59

    If I push your head in to wall like you can see in the picture (and dont tell me its hockey) criminal intant is the cops biz.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    james ferguson
    - March 17, 2011 at 10:38:39

    I saw the actually hit by the boston player and I did not feel that he intended to injure. If the owner or owners of the rink were aware of the condition of the boards or stanchion and the hazard that existed and done nothing to correct it, then they should be held responible.

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Westmount Examiner is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts
loading...

Advertising